Very Good Counseling EMDR Therapy Because You Matter

Life Coach or Therapist: Best Guide to Your Best Self?

Apr 21, 2024 | 0 comments


The information provided here is not intended to be a substitute for professional health and mental health care or consultation. Individuals who believe they may require or benefit from treatment should seek the advice of a psychologist or other licensed mental health professional.

Very Good Counseling is a private practice of licensed mental health therapists who specialize in EMDR.  We provide online mental health services to individuals throughout the State of Florida,  and in-person at our office in Fort Myers, FL. For more information, contact us.

by: <a href="" target="_blank">Robert Engle, EMDRIA-Approved EMDR Therapist</a>

by: Robert Engle, EMDRIA-Approved EMDR Therapist

Because We Believe You Matter

Robert joined the practice full time in 2022 to help neurodivergent individuals with ADHD, anxiety, and depression find freedom and enjoy life through counseling. He is currently working towards becoming a Certified ADHD Professional (ADHD-CCSP). Trained in EMDR therapy, he excels at understanding the intricacies of ADHD and Trauma.

Imagine standing at a crossroads in your life, surrounded by a fog of uncertainty. You’re torn between following the path you’ve always known and venturing into the unknown in search of something more. This pivotal moment often prompts the search for guidance, prompting individuals to seek support from a trusted source – a life coach or therapist. In their expertise lies the promise of clarity, purpose, and self-discovery.

 It’s a feeling many of us have experienced, that pivotal moment when we realize we need guidance to navigate the complexities of our own minds and hearts. This is where the expertise of a life coach or therapist can make all the difference.

The path to a greater sense of personal fulfillment is a journey filled with ups and downs, but it’s also an opportunity for growth and self-discovery. Whether you’re facing challenges, seeking fulfillment, or simply trying to understand yourself better, the quest for purpose and authenticity is universal. 

Navigating the choice between a life coach or a therapist can feel like standing at a crossroads with no signposts, unsure which path to take. The decision weighs heavy, as each offers unique approaches and support systems tailored to different needs. 

It’s natural to feel overwhelmed by the decision, especially when you’re longing for guidance and support. You might find yourself torn between the structured strategies offered by a life coach and the compassionate listening provided by a therapist, unsure of which path will best meet your needs.

Understanding the differences between these roles is crucial, as the right information can make all the difference in finding the support that resonates with you. Making the choice between hiring a life coach or seeing a therapist is much about recognizing what you find yourself facing and choosing the path that aligns best with your current journey.

The right information can be a guiding light, illuminating the way forward and helping you make a choice that feels right for you. Remember, you’re not alone in this journey. In this blog post, we’ll explore how a life coach or therapist can help you find the sense of clarity you seek.

Do I Need a Life Coach or a Therapist? Things to Consider

In deciding between working with a life coach or seeing a therapist, the ultimate goal is to make a decision that aligns with your needs, preferences, and desired outcomes. While it’s essential to trust your instincts and consider how you feel about yourself and your goals, sometimes it can be helpful to take a step back and gather a selection of key factors. 

When you’re deeply immersed in your personal journey, for example, it’s natural to feel like you’re navigating through a dense fog. Emotions, fears, and desires can create a haze that makes it more challenging to see the path ahead clearly. Having a handly list of additional factors to help guide your choice can serve you like friendly beacons in the night, offering a fresh perspective and a gentle nudge towards clarity. 

Consider factors such as your specific goals and challenges, your comfort level with different approaches, your past experiences with coaching or therapy, and the professional expertise of the individuals you’re considering working with. Each factor brings its own unique perspective to the table, helping you weigh the pros and cons of each option more effectively.

Here are a few considerations you may want to have on your list:

1. Goals and Objectives: 

Consider what you hope to achieve through your sessions and whether your goals are more aligned with practical, goal-oriented outcomes or deeper emotional exploration and healing.

2. Current Challenges: 

Assess the specific challenges you’re facing in your life, whether they are related to career, relationships, personal development, or mental health, and determine which professional is best equipped to address them.

3. Comfort Level:

 Reflect on your comfort level with structured, goal-oriented approaches versus more open-ended, exploratory methods of support, and choose the approach that resonates most with you.

4. Personal Preferences: 

Take into account your preferences for communication style, coaching/therapy techniques, and the overall dynamic of the client-coach or client-therapist relationship.

5. Past Experiences: 

Consider any past experiences you’ve had with coaching, therapy, or related support services, and assess what worked well for you and what didn’t.

6. Budget and Accessibility: 

Evaluate the financial considerations and accessibility of both life coaching and therapy services, including factors such as cost, insurance coverage, location, and availability of appointments.

7. Severity of Issues: 

Determine the severity of the issues you’re facing and whether they require immediate attention and intervention from a therapist or can be addressed through coaching for personal development and growth.

8. Professional Expertise: 

Take into account the professional qualifications, training, and expertise of the life coach or therapist, ensuring they have the skills and experience necessary to support you effectively.

9. Desired Outcomes: 

Clarify your expectations and desired outcomes for the coaching or therapy process, and choose the option that aligns best with your vision for personal growth, well-being, and fulfillment.

10. Flexibility and Commitment: 

Assess your readiness and willingness to commit to the coaching or therapy process, including factors such as scheduling flexibility, session frequency, and long-term commitment to personal development.

By considering these factors thoughtfully and weighing your options carefully, you can make a better informed decision between life coach or therapist. You may gain a clearer overall perspective and it can shed new light on any preconceived notions you may have about either role. And remember, whether you choose to work with a life coach or see a therapist, the most important thing is that you’re taking proactive steps towards your own growth and well-being.

In the upcoming sections, we’ll take a deeper look into the roles of both life coaches and therapists, giving you a clearer understanding of what to expect and ways each may support you on your journey to self-discovery and growth. Stay tuned!

What to Expect from a Life Coach

In today’s fast-paced world, many of us find ourselves searching for deeper meaning, greater fulfillment, and a clearer sense of direction. We yearn for guidance, support, and encouragement as we navigate the complexities of our lives. Enter the life coach – a dedicated ally on your journey towards personal growth and transformation.

At its core, the role of a life coach is to empower you to identify and achieve your goals, overcome obstacles, and create positive change in your life. Unlike therapists who focus on healing past wounds or diagnosing mental health conditions, life coaches are forward-focused, helping you to clarify your vision for the future and take actionable steps towards making it a reality.

Life coaching is experiencing a surge in popularity for several reasons. First, in today’s fast-paced world, many individuals are seeking greater clarity, purpose, and fulfillment in their lives. Second, the rise of self-care and personal development movements has led to increased awareness and interest in holistic approaches to well-being.

It’s also important to note that this doesn’t mean a therapist can’t be of powerful help in these areas. For some professionals driven to affect change in the lives of others, life coaching is simply a more accessible career path compared to becoming a therapist. 

Enthusiastic life coaches are putting themselves out there on social media, compelling individuals to use their services, leading to more in-the-moment decisions to work with a life coach, driven by the immediate appeal and promises of personal transformation and resulting in the increased popularity of this role. 

Life coaching provides a holistic framework for growth that encompasses not just professional success, but also personal fulfillment, relationships, and overall happiness. Additionally, the accessibility of life coaching, with many coaches offering virtual sessions and flexible scheduling, makes it a convenient option for individuals with busy lifestyles. 

Finally, the positive testimonials and success stories from those who have experienced the transformative power of life coaching have helped to fuel its popularity, as word-of-mouth recommendations continue to spread. Overall, as more people recognize the value of investing in their personal growth and well-being, the demand for life coaching and similar services continues to grow.

But what can you expect from a life coach, and what does a life coach do exactly? Let’s explore.

Tailored Support for Your Unique Journey

One of the most exciting aspects of working with a life coach is the personalized support they provide. Whether you’re striving to advance your career, improve your relationships, or enhance your overall well-being, a skilled life coach will tailor their approach to meet your specific needs and aspirations. Through thoughtful questioning, active listening, and insightful feedback, they’ll help you uncover your strengths, values, and passions, guiding you towards alignment with your true self.

Goal Setting and Accountability

A hallmark of life coaching is its emphasis on goal setting and accountability. Together with your coach, you’ll define clear, measurable objectives that align with your values and aspirations. Your coach will then support you in creating action plans, breaking down barriers, and staying accountable to your commitments. With their guidance and encouragement, you’ll develop the skills, habits, and mindset necessary to overcome challenges and achieve success.

Empowering Mindset Shifts

Beyond setting and achieving specific goals, life coaching often involves cultivating a mindset of growth, resilience, and self-belief. Your coach will help you identify and challenge limiting beliefs, replace negative self-talk with empowering affirmations, and cultivate a sense of confidence and optimism in your abilities. Through this process, you’ll learn to embrace challenges as opportunities for growth, cultivate resilience in the face of adversity, and unleash your full potential.

Building Lasting Transformation

Perhaps the most profound impact of working with a life coach is the lasting transformation it can facilitate in your life. By embarking on this journey of self-discovery and personal growth, you’ll not only achieve your immediate goals but also develop a deeper understanding of yourself, your values, and your purpose. Armed with newfound clarity and confidence, you’ll navigate life’s challenges with greater ease, pursue your passions with renewed vigor, and create a life that’s truly aligned with your authentic self.

Life Coach or Therapist: How Much Do Life Coaches Charge? 

When it comes to the financial aspects of seeking support through either life coaching or therapy, it’s essential to explore the intricacies of budgeting. Both avenues offer invaluable guidance and assistance on our journey towards personal growth and well-being, yet they present differing cost structures that can influence our decision-making process.

Life coaching rates can vary significantly, spanning from $75 to $200 per hour, with some elite coaches commanding several hundred dollars per hour. This broad spectrum of pricing is influenced by various factors including the coach’s experience, specialization, and geographic location. While the variability in rates may seem daunting, it also offers individuals the opportunity to find a coach whose fees align with their budget and goals.

Therapy sessions, on the other hand, typically range from $125 to $175 per hour for those paying out-of-pocket, making it a generally more affordable option compared to high-end life coaching services. The consistency in pricing within the therapy realm can provide a sense of financial predictability, allowing individuals to plan and budget accordingly for their sessions.

In considering the financial investment required for either life coaching or therapy, however, it’s essential to shift our focus beyond the price tag alone. While affordability is undoubtedly a critical factor, we must also weigh the importance of this investment and the potential impact it will have on our lives – our return on investment, if you will. 

Investing in our personal growth and well-being can yield immeasurable benefits, from enhanced self-awareness and resilience to improved relationships and career satisfaction. By prioritizing our well-being and committing to our personal growth journey, we can cultivate a richer, more fulfilling life that transcends monetary considerations.

Ultimately, the decision between life coaching vs. therapy should be made with careful consideration of both financial feasibility and the value proposition offered by each option. It’s about striking a balance between obtaining services that are within our means and recognizing the transformative potential of investing in ourselves.

What to Expect from Seeing a Therapist

While life coaching is fantastic for setting goals and achieving them, therapy is like the heart and soul of personal growth. It’s that safe haven where you can lay bare your deepest thoughts, fears, and emotions without any judgment whatsoever. It’s like having a trusted confidant who holds space for you to explore the depths of your psyche, untangle the knots in your mind, and shed light on those dark corners you may have been avoiding.

Unlike a life coach, your therapist isn’t there to tell you what to do or how to live your life; they’re there to walk alongside you on your journey of self-discovery and healing. Therapy is a process of peeling back the layers of yourself, layer by layer, until you reach the core of who you are. It’s like tending to the wounds of your soul, one gentle step at a time. 

Your therapist provides you with the tools, the insights, and the support you need to heal from past traumas, release pent-up emotions, and cultivate a sense of inner peace and wholeness. It’s a journey of self-discovery and transformation that can be both challenging and profoundly rewarding, ultimately leading to a deeper understanding of yourself and a greater sense of empowerment.

The Therapy Experience

Entering therapy can feel like embarking on a journey into the depths of your inner world. Unlike the structured goal-setting sessions often associated with life coaching, therapy sessions provide a safe and supportive space for individuals to explore their thoughts, emotions, and experiences without judgment. Therapists, trained mental health professionals, utilize a variety of therapeutic modalities, including talk therapy, cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), and psychodynamic therapy, to help clients understand and navigate their inner landscape.

Talking to Your Therapist

Talking to your therapist is a deeply personal and intimate experience. Therapists are skilled listeners who offer empathetic support and guidance as you explore your thoughts, feelings, and experiences. Unlike the more direct approach often used in life coaching, therapy sessions are client-centered, allowing individuals to lead the conversation and explore topics at their own pace. This process of self-exploration and reflection can be both challenging and rewarding, leading to profound insights and personal growth.

What to Expect in Therapy

When you enter therapy, you can expect to embark on a journey of self-discovery and healing. Your therapist will work collaboratively with you to identify and explore areas of concern, set therapeutic goals, and develop strategies for coping and healing. Depending on your needs and preferences, therapy may involve exploring past experiences, processing emotions, challenging negative thought patterns, and learning new coping skills. The therapeutic relationship, built on trust, empathy, and authenticity, serves as a foundation for growth and transformation.

Specialized Therapeutic Modalities

One of the unique aspects of seeing a therapist vs. life coaching is the availability of specialized therapeutic modalities designed to address specific concerns and issues. For example, Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) is a therapeutic approach used to treat trauma and PTSD by processing distressing memories and experiences. Other modalities, such as mindfulness-based therapies and dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), offer tools and techniques for managing anxiety, depression, and other mental health challenges. These specialized approaches provide targeted support and intervention that may not be available through life coaching alone.

How to Find Your Passion and Purpose: Life Coach or Therapist

The journey to discover your passion and purpose is a quest that resonates deeply with many of us. It’s that innate longing to find meaning, fulfillment, and authenticity in life that is often the top factor compelling individuals to seek guidance and support. And while it may seem like different motivations are driving the search – whether it’s career dissatisfaction, relationship struggles, or a general sense of restlessness – at the core, what’s really being sought is clarity, direction, and a sense of purpose.

It’s in this quest for passion and purpose that both life coaches and therapists can provide invaluable, transformative support and guidance. After all, each profession brings its own unique set of tools, perspectives, and approaches to the table, helping individuals from all statuses and walks of life navigate the complex terrain of self-discovery and personal growth that inevitably must be traversed.

Indeed, many life coaches excel at helping clients clarify their goals, identify their passions, and create actionable plans to pursue their dreams. Through powerful questioning, goal-setting exercises, and accountability measures, they empower clients to step into their full potential and live a life aligned with their deepest desires. Life coaches are often like your personal cheerleaders, cheering you on as you take bold steps towards your dreams and aspirations.

On the other hand, therapists provide a different kind of support in the pursuit of passion and purpose. Through deep emotional exploration and healing, therapists help individuals uncover the underlying beliefs, fears, and traumas that may be blocking their path to fulfillment. By processing past experiences, challenging limiting beliefs, and cultivating self-awareness, therapists assist clients in removing the barriers that prevent them from living authentically and pursuing their passions with confidence.

Still,recognizing the limitations of each role when it comes to this specific focus can help make the choice between them clearer. While life coaches can provide practical strategies and motivation to pursue your passions, they may not always have the expertise or training to address deep-seated emotional issues that may be holding you back. Conversely, while therapists offer a safe space for emotional exploration and healing, they may not always focus on concrete goal-setting and action planning to help you manifest your dreams.

In essence, the real key lies in knowing when to seek support from a life coach and when to turn to a therapist in your pursuit of passion and purpose. Sometimes, it may be beneficial to work with both professionals concurrently, leveraging the strengths of each to create a holistic approach to personal growth and transformation.

In a Nutshell: Life Coach or Therapist

So, now we’ve reached the crossroads of deciding whether to seek support from a life coach or a therapist. It’s a big decision, and one that requires careful consideration of your needs, goals, and preferences. But fear not, we can effectively navigate this maze of choices with clarity and confidence.

Signs You Should See a Therapist:

  • You’re struggling with persistent feelings of sadness, anxiety, or hopelessness.
  • Past traumas or unresolved issues are impacting your daily life and relationships.
  • You’re experiencing difficulty coping with stress, grief, or major life changes.
  • Your mental health symptoms are interfering with your ability to function effectively at work, school, or home.
  • You’re engaging in self-destructive behaviors such as substance abuse, self-harm, or disordered eating.
  • You’re experiencing significant challenges in your relationships or have difficulty forming healthy connections.
  • You have a history of mental health conditions such as depression, anxiety disorders, or PTSD.

Signs You Should See a Life Coach:

  • You’re feeling stuck or unfulfilled in your career and want to explore new opportunities or make a career change.
  • You’re struggling to set and achieve goals in your personal or professional life.
  • You want to improve your time management, productivity, or organizational skills.
  • You’re seeking clarity and direction in your life but don’t have any underlying mental health concerns.
  • You’re ready to step out of your comfort zone and pursue your passions and dreams with confidence.
  • You want to enhance your communication skills, assertiveness, or self-confidence.
  • You’re seeking accountability and support to stay motivated and focused on your goals.

The Pros and Cons of Life Coaches:


  • Empowerment: Life coaches empower clients to take control of their lives and make positive changes.
  • Goal Setting: Life coaches help clients clarify their goals and create actionable plans to achieve them.
  • Accountability: Life coaches provide accountability and support to help clients stay motivated and focused.
  • Forward-Focused: Life coaching is future-oriented, focusing on creating a fulfilling and meaningful life.


  • Limited Scope: Life coaches may not have the training or expertise to address deep-seated emotional issues.
  • Lack of Regulation: The life coaching industry is not regulated, so anyone can call themselves a life coach regardless of their qualifications.
  • Cost: High-end life coaching services can be expensive, making them inaccessible to some individuals.

The Pros and Cons of Therapists:


  • Expertise: Therapists are trained mental health professionals with expertise in addressing a wide range of mental health concerns.
  • Emotional Support: Therapists provide a safe and supportive space for clients to explore their thoughts, feelings, and experiences.
  • Evidence-Based Techniques: Therapists utilize evidence-based techniques and therapeutic modalities to help clients heal and grow.
  • Insurance Coverage: Therapy sessions may be covered by health insurance, making them more affordable for some individuals.


  • Stigma: There is still a stigma surrounding therapy and mental health treatment, which may prevent some individuals from seeking help.
  • Time Commitment: Therapy requires a significant time commitment, with sessions typically lasting 45 to 60 minutes.
  • Finding the Right Fit: It may take time to find a therapist who is the right fit for you, leading to potential frustration and disappointment.

In the end, whether you choose to work with a life coach or a therapist, the most important thing is to prioritize your well-being and take proactive steps towards personal growth and fulfillment. Trust your instincts, do your research, and don’t be afraid to reach out for support when you need it. Your journey towards a happier, healthier life all starts with a single step.

Start your healing journey with us. 

Not to brag, but we’re Very Good.

Most Recent Posts

from the Very Good Blog


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *